Sell Magic Cards

Sell Magic Cards Near Me


We are happy to educate you on your collection and give you a professional appraisal of its value, even if you are not looking to sell.



We consistently offer higher prices than other comic buyers. This is because we keep our overhead costs low and have a loyal customer base.



We will meet with you at a time and place of your convenience. This can be at your place, our showroom, or somewhere in-between.



Our very experienced buyers are always willing to evaluate your collectables and offer a vast amount of knowledge about your collectables.

Sell old magic cards

Should you really sell magic cards?

Deciding whether to sell magic cards now or later is something to think about. Firstly, evaluate your reasoning for selling the cards. If you still play and love the game, then it might not be the right time to sell. However, if you want a free evaluation of your cards, we offer that service.

You may be passionate about it, but before you decide to sell magic cards - you may need some professional help. Because cards in your possession may be worth more than you think. A professional evaluation is important if you want to get as much money as possible. But where to find a place to sell magic cards?

How to Sell Magic Cards in Libertyville?

There are few main options if you decided to sell magic cards in Libertyville:

  • Specialized online forums. 
  • Online marketplaces.
  • Local collectors.
  • And others!
  • But before you find your own best way to sell magic cards, you may want to get an actual professional evaluation of your collection. As we said earlier, cards you have may actually be worth way more than you think. At Comic Buying Center (do not let the name fool you), we are passionate about what we do and we are passionate about magic cards. 

    But we are also professionals, so if you need an expert evaluation - we can absolutely do that. Before you sell your beloved collection, please contact us.

    Sell Magic Cards Libertyville

    sell your comic books?

      Sell magic cards for cash

      Comic Buying Center in Libertyville, IL - Best Place to Sell Magic Cards

      Here’s why it would be a good idea to sell magic cards for cash to us:

    • Expert Evaluation. As we said before, we’re not just passionate about what we do - we are experts. And as experts, we can make an accurate and professional evaluation of your collection so you would know its honest price. 
    • As Smooth as Possible. We’re in business for years now. And that’s why our selling/buying process is smooth and hustle-free. 
    • Convenience and Reputation. As a Libertyville local shop we value our reputation, and we want our community to like us.. 
    • We’re Buying More. Are you looking for a place to sell comic books? Or you want to sell video games? We can help with this too! By the way, if you decide to work with us, you don’t even need to go to us - we can come to you! 
    • Collectors Network. We have connection to an extensive network of magic cards collectors which allows us to find best buyers for your cards, making our offers as aggressive as possible. 
    • Working with us makes everything easier. We want to help you sell your magic cards while making this process smooth and easy. Trust Comic Buying Center as the best place to sell magic cards in Libertyville.

      What we sell


      We are available to appraise and/or purchase your collectables from Monday through Saturday 10 am until 5 pm. If those times don’t work for you, we can try to accommodate your schedule. We always recommend making an appointment with us, but it is not necessary.


      We travel the country every year buying collections. We are happy to have one of our professionals come to you to evaluate your collectibles and make a fair purchase offer.

      Common questions about selling magic cards

      Does the Comic Buying Center buy Magic: The Gathering cards?

      Yes, we do purchase Magic: The Gathering (MTG) cards. We are interested in a wide range of cards, from classic sets to the latest releases. You are welcome to bring your MTG cards to our center for assessment.

      What types of MTG cards are most sought after by the Comic Buying Center?

      We're particularly interested in rare, mythic, or foil cards, cards from older sets, complete sets, and cards in mint or near-mint condition. However, we consider all kinds of MTG cards, including common and uncommon ones.

      How does the Comic Buying Center determine the value of MTG cards?

      Our valuation is based on the card's rarity, condition, demand, and current market prices. We use well-known price guides and databases, alongside our expertise in the MTG market, to offer fair prices for your cards.

      What is the best way to present my MTG cards for sale or trade?

      To ensure a smooth evaluation process, please keep your cards in good condition. Store them in protective sleeves or binders and sort them in a way that is easy to review, such as by set, color, or rarity.

      Does the Comic Buying Center have any specific guidelines for evaluating MTG card collections?

      For larger collections, we recommend contacting us in advance to schedule an evaluation. This allows us to allocate sufficient time and resources to thoroughly assess your collection. We evaluate collections based on individual card values as well as the overall completeness and diversity of the set.

      Our Reviews

      Comic Buying Center
      Based on 40 reviews
      powered by Google
      Had some comics to sell for a relative. Explained the whole process up front. Great, easy, smooth, experience. Thank you.
      Joe FriedensonJoe Friedenson
      01:03 05 Jan 24
      Mike MulveyMike Mulvey
      14:48 26 Dec 23
      I came here on my lunch break and this place is awesome! Staff was super friendly. The selection of comics and trades was insane. Even their binder of MTG cards had a great selection. I plan on going back very soon!
      Darksiderkid12 _Darksiderkid12 _
      17:54 16 Dec 23
      Huge selection
      sajay kanapillysajay kanapilly
      04:36 14 Dec 23
      Wonderful experience at Comic Buying Center today! I contacted Mike and we set an appointment to possibly sell my comics. Mike was so knowledgeable and friendly. He showed me around the store, offered me something to drink and walked me thru the buying process. HONEST. Very refreshing to experience. He offered me a great and fair price and we were done. It was so relaxed we ended up talking a little about our lives outside of comics. Great time today. Thanks Mike!
      Cris HauckCris Hauck
      15:08 07 Oct 23
      I was recently tasked with selling the large comics collection (around 7000 comics), of a relative’s estate. It was almost all DC silver age comics. Peter came to my home in Wisconsin and carefully walked through the process with me and made a very fair offer that day. His knowledge, experience and thoughtfulness made this a very pleasant experience. I’m so glad I called them first!
      Jim MarkusJim Markus
      16:29 05 Oct 23
      K RK R
      16:08 27 Sep 23
      This place is amazing! I can spend hours going through the hundreds of back issues in stock and constantly find amazing issues for cheap. I love visiting this place!
      Sue PechanSue Pechan
      17:43 21 Sep 23
      Mike is very nice, and he has lots of stuff for sale.
      Matthew GlassmakerMatthew Glassmaker
      22:31 14 Sep 23
      Very pleasant people to deal with. First time doing business with and couldn’t have been more smooth.
      01:27 17 Aug 23
      They drove out to me to buy my comics. They were very fair, knowledgeable, and friendly. I plan on continuing to do business with them and I would strongly recommend them if you are buying or selling comics!
      Martin BoyerMartin Boyer
      20:52 28 Jul 23
      Very impressed with this center, and their expertise in comics. Mike and the team were very welcoming, from my initial phone call to my store visit. Gave me a very fair price on my small collection, and showed me cool items that I hope to return to take a look at.Thank you!
      Jeff HJeff H
      12:02 22 Jul 23
      Selling my collection to these guys was a very pleasant experience. I got a fair price for my comics and, I’m glad they’ll go to collectors who’ll value them. I highly recommend this company.
      Kari FrazierKari Frazier
      18:00 19 Apr 22
      Randomly stopped by because we saw the “Comics 4 Less Store OPEN” sign on the street. A little weird to get into the building because there’s no other signage, but the comics inside were awesome! $2 for issues, $5 for trades. Great quality and selection. Really nice guys too! Definitely will come back.

      Contact us anytime


      Message Us

      Opening Hours

      Mon - Sat: 10am - 5pm