01
FREE APPRAISALS
We are happy to educate you on your collection and give you a professional appraisal of its value, even if you are not looking to sell.
02
TOP PRICES PAID
We consistently offer higher prices than other comic buyers. This is because we keep our overhead costs low and have a loyal customer base.
03
ALWAYS OPEN
We will meet with you at a time and place of your convenience. This can be at your place, our showroom, or somewhere in-between.
04
Expertise
Our very experienced buyers are always willing to evaluate your collectables and offer a vast amount of knowledge about your collectables.
Most Popular Magic: The Gathering Sets
Should you really sell magic cards?
Deciding whether to sell magic cards now or later is something to think about. Firstly, evaluate your reasoning for selling the cards. If you still play and love the game, then it might not be the right time to sell. However, if you want a free evaluation of your cards, we offer that service.
You may be passionate about it, but before you decide to sell magic cards - you may need some professional help. Because cards in your possession may be worth more than you think. A professional evaluation is important if you want to get as much money as possible. But where to find a place to sell magic cards?
How to Sell Magic Cards in Libertyville?
There are few main options if you decided to sell magic cards in Libertyville:
But before you find your own best way to sell magic cards, you may want to get an actual professional evaluation of your collection. As we said earlier, cards you have may actually be worth way more than you think. At Comic Buying Center (do not let the name fool you), we are passionate about what we do and we are passionate about magic cards.
But we are also professionals, so if you need an expert evaluation - we can absolutely do that. Before you sell your beloved collection, please contact us.
Ready
to sell your
comic books?
Comic Buying Center in Libertyville, IL - Best Place to Sell Magic Cards
Here’s why it would be a good idea to sell magic cards for cash to us:
Working with us makes everything easier. We want to help you sell your magic cards while making this process smooth and easy. Trust Comic Buying Center as the best place to sell magic cards in Libertyville.
What we sell
YOU CAN VISIT US
We are available to appraise and/or purchase your collectables from Monday through Saturday 10 am until 5 pm. If those times don’t work for you, we can try to accommodate your schedule. We always recommend making an appointment with us, but it is not necessary.
WE CAN VISIT YOU
We travel the country every year buying collections. We are happy to have one of our professionals come to you to evaluate your collectibles and make a fair purchase offer.
Common questions about selling magic cards
Where to sell magic cards?
You can sell your Magic cards at Comic Buying Center. We specialize in buying Magic: The Gathering collections and offer competitive prices. You are welcome to bring your MTG cards to our center for assessment.
What types of MTG cards are most sought after by the Comic Buying Center?
We're particularly interested in rare, mythic, or foil cards, cards from older sets, complete sets, and cards in mint or near-mint condition. However, we consider all kinds of MTG cards, including common and uncommon ones.
How does the Comic Buying Center determine the value of MTG cards?
Our valuation is based on the card's rarity, condition, demand, and current market prices. We use well-known price guides and databases, alongside our expertise in the MTG market, to offer fair prices for your cards.
What is the best way to present my MTG cards for sale or trade?
To ensure a smooth evaluation process, please keep your cards in good condition. Store them in protective sleeves or binders and sort them in a way that is easy to review, such as by set, color, or rarity.
Does the Comic Buying Center have any specific guidelines for evaluating MTG card collections?
For larger collections, we recommend contacting us in advance to schedule an evaluation. This allows us to allocate sufficient time and resources to thoroughly assess your collection. We evaluate collections based on individual card values as well as the overall completeness and diversity of the set.
Our Reviews
Selling was a fair and enjoyable experience. They took the time to explain their method and look up current prices. It was a friendly atmosphere and there was no pressure to sell books if we had different opinions on value. I sold them nearly 2000 books without having to advertise or deal with the post office! Thanks!
I so grateful to work with Mike at Comic Buying Center. This person was not only great to talk to, but got me fantastic Silver Age comics I was looking for at a great price and was very generous and patient. I will be going back no doubt. Thank you for making a dream place for collectors!
We found a bunch of 1940’s-era comics in my late-father’s belongings and took them here to sell. Peter was extremely friendly and knowledgeable, explaining what the comics were worth and why. In the end, I feel like I received a fair price for them and thoroughly enjoyed being in the store. Highly recommend!
So, I have been through the hassle before of trying to sell Magic Cards. Store credit here, not a fair offer there, and I’ve run the gauntlet of rude shop owners. But not these guys. These guys are what every shop owner should try to be.
Dorian and Jared put me 100% at ease right away. They explained their process, made sure I understood what they could offer, even let me sit and joke with them while they worked on my cards. I had some good stuff and I could tell they love their jobs because of the genuine excitement just going through the collection. It was a bit of a drive for me, so I would say call and talk to them first, just so you can be sure the trip is worth it. But if you live a little closer and need a place that will show your collection the respect it unequivocally deserves, look no further.
I have more to sell and a wish list of comics I’d like to get my hands on. Maybe even that sweet game cube in the vintage video game room if it’s still there. I will be going back for sure.
Dorian and Jared put me 100% at ease right away. They explained their process, made sure I understood what they could offer, even let me sit and joke with them while they worked on my cards. I had some good stuff and I could tell they love their jobs because of the genuine excitement just going through the collection. It was a bit of a drive for me, so I would say call and talk to them first, just so you can be sure the trip is worth it. But if you live a little closer and need a place that will show your collection the respect it unequivocally deserves, look no further.
I have more to sell and a wish list of comics I’d like to get my hands on. Maybe even that sweet game cube in the vintage video game room if it’s still there. I will be going back for sure.
After a brief intro phone call last week, Mike came in from the suburbs to my house in Chicago today and spent several hours evaluating my 3,600-book collection. He’s a true pro and a nice guy.
I decided I would probably sell to CBC after hearing about their program of setting out lightly picked boxes (major keys pulled) at five bucks a book at the beginning of the month and then dropping the price to a buck on remaining stock at the end of the month. Cool way to keep the collectors engaged and give them a shot at some nice finds. Those are the kind of people you want to do business with.
If you are selling a collection, the biggest difference between having a positive experience and a bad one is in setting realistic expectations. I told Mike I wanted us both to do well in the transaction and that I know guide prices often don’t reflect market realities. After that, it was a mellow process marked by good conversation.
The price we negotiated was a fair one and I felt this collection–which I built from the ages of 7 to 16 from a combo of diligently buying new books and making the rounds of second-hand stores back in the days when you could stumble on an entire box of Silver Age superhero titles for cover price–was going to a good home.
If I sent the major keys out to be graded and sold them individually on eBay, I probably could have tripled the payout, but I don’t have the time or inclination to do that. CBC will very likely double the money, which is perfectly fair. The collection was assembled with passion and I smile at the thought of collectors going through my 15 long boxes and fishing out some gems.
I would recommend these guys to any collector looking to sell. If I was still a kid, I’m sure I’d be camped out there on the first day of every month. Thanks, Mike.
I decided I would probably sell to CBC after hearing about their program of setting out lightly picked boxes (major keys pulled) at five bucks a book at the beginning of the month and then dropping the price to a buck on remaining stock at the end of the month. Cool way to keep the collectors engaged and give them a shot at some nice finds. Those are the kind of people you want to do business with.
If you are selling a collection, the biggest difference between having a positive experience and a bad one is in setting realistic expectations. I told Mike I wanted us both to do well in the transaction and that I know guide prices often don’t reflect market realities. After that, it was a mellow process marked by good conversation.
The price we negotiated was a fair one and I felt this collection–which I built from the ages of 7 to 16 from a combo of diligently buying new books and making the rounds of second-hand stores back in the days when you could stumble on an entire box of Silver Age superhero titles for cover price–was going to a good home.
If I sent the major keys out to be graded and sold them individually on eBay, I probably could have tripled the payout, but I don’t have the time or inclination to do that. CBC will very likely double the money, which is perfectly fair. The collection was assembled with passion and I smile at the thought of collectors going through my 15 long boxes and fishing out some gems.
I would recommend these guys to any collector looking to sell. If I was still a kid, I’m sure I’d be camped out there on the first day of every month. Thanks, Mike.
Very impressed with the tons of comics here! Originally came to sell some magic cards and a few old video game gems. Dorian took good care and time with my cards and gave a very fair offer. So happy that I randomly found these guys searching google. Apparently, they’re going to be expanding a video game section in the summer. Will definitely be back and would recommend
Great place! I generally go here when I’m wanting to buy comics during the summer. Their $5 Trade Paperback section is my favortie part of the store and I’ve bought multiple from them over the past few years. The prices are always fair and all the staff I’ve interacted with are really friendly. I’m very happy to support this local buisness instead of having to spend tons of money on Amazon.
My kids love going there to look through the longboxes. They have 100K+ comics! They offer free candy and drinks to customers. They also provide free short or longboxes to customers who buy enough comics to fill them
On the last 5 business days of every month, all comics in the main room are $1! Otherwise, they’re $2.
On the last 5 business days of every month, all comics in the main room are $1! Otherwise, they’re $2.
Best value on old video games and systems in town! Selling and buying, they know their stuff here and make sure all customers are taken care of! I wanted to max my old Nintendo game collection value – but FB Marketplace was intense and GameStop offers pennies – then I was lucky enough to hear about the Comic Buying Center. I am very happy with the trade we made and even scooped up some new treasures while I was there.
I cannot say enough about the fine folks at Comic Buying Center. Their team of professionals were knowledgeable, courteous, and honest.
The shop itself was clean, well-organized, fairly priced, and had a vast assortment of comics, games, and Magic cards.
A special shout out to Dorian who went above and beyond. He came in on his ONE DAY OFF to appraise my collection after he heard I drove two hours to meet with him. I could tell he’s a collector himself who genuinely enjoys his work which shows in his interactions with you and items you wish to sell.
Highly recommend. I’ll be sending both buyers and sellers here in the future 🙂
The shop itself was clean, well-organized, fairly priced, and had a vast assortment of comics, games, and Magic cards.
A special shout out to Dorian who went above and beyond. He came in on his ONE DAY OFF to appraise my collection after he heard I drove two hours to meet with him. I could tell he’s a collector himself who genuinely enjoys his work which shows in his interactions with you and items you wish to sell.
Highly recommend. I’ll be sending both buyers and sellers here in the future 🙂
Staff SO helpful and welcoming for my first time there. Great MTG selection–it was unwise of me to go unsupervised with a fresh paycheck in my pocket! They pay very close attention to pricing based on current market price and condition. Can’t wait to go back when I have more time!
I just sold my entire game collection to Comic Buying Center and let me yell you..it was an Amazing experience!I highly recomend them, with their expert knowledge and appraising.Thank you Dorian
These guys are the best!! I inquired about 2 CGC graded books and got a great deal!! Mike provided me with excellent customer service and communication!! I give my highest recommendation!!!
Staff are super helpful and knowledgeable. Unbelievable selection of vintage comics! My new favorite place! Highly recommend
This shop is amazing, has such a huge variety of comic books and games and cards I couldn’t believe it. The guys there are super nice and friendly and selling comic books was fast and easy and they were very fair in pricing, highly recommend!!
I had a fantastic experience selling my PS4 games to Dorian and Mike. They were super friendly, professional, and made the whole process smooth and hassle-free. Their knowledge of games made the transaction even better. If you’re looking for honest and reliable buyers, I highly recommend them. Thanks again, Dorian and Mike!
Comic book heaven! Tons of cheap back issues to look through. Great selection of wall books and higher grade as well. Videos games, funko pops, trade paperbacks! The staff is the best and go out of their way to make everyone feel welcome.
An amazing seller! Great inventory and always willing to help find those missing pieces from your collection. Great prices and amazing inventory. Highly recommend!
Thanks to Dorian who helped me during my visit. He is very knowledgeable, fair and all around a great person. The store is awesome and i compare it to a treasure hunt as you can find a hidden gem anywhere. The selection is SICK! Go here, especially if you’re looking for old school stuff. I was immediately filled with nostalgia as I roamed the building. Thanks Dorian.
Great to work with. Very accommodating & fair in their buying & selling of comics.
While I live far away, i’m definitely going back.
While I live far away, i’m definitely going back.
Fantastic experience today. Went to sell most of my collection and was met by amazing staff who helped me bring in all my stuff. Pete spent a lot of time with me and was patient with my questions while providing thorough answers and insight. I was never made to feel rushed and I felt Pete gave me a very honest appraisal/offer. I must also say that the store itself is fun to look around. Great selection of comics as well as video games, consoles, and other collectibles. This place was definitely a hidden gem for me. I highly recommend visiting Pete and the staff at Comic Buying Center whether you want to sell something or just want to browse their amazing in-store selection.
I’ve been collecting rare comic book slabs for about 6 months now. My son (4.5) has seen them and kept asking if we could read one. I looked up a place locally that carried them since I’d bought most of them from online auction sites. This was the first one that popped up. We went to get him his very first TMNT comic and right when we walked in we were greeted by an incredibly knowledgeable and friendly staff. (they really leaned in to make it a special experience for him. The owner Peter, came over and also showed me their collection of CGC Slabs and it was extensive. He also took a wish list from me to call as they came in. 10/10 would recommend!
Called a few weeks ago about a conic collection I acquired. Was given great advice by Mike & ultimately stopped in. Mike was great, giving us a full tour of the facility & a detailed explanation about the grading & pricing process. Great experience, honest & trustworthy, professional & courteous, great selling experience for us. Highly recommend & I’ll be back for more transactions!
Jim / Racine, WI
Jim / Racine, WI
I was looking to sell some old Magic: The Gathering cards that I had sitting around in my basement for YEARS. My wife happened to find this business while helping me look for locations. I called them on a Friday afternoon and Dorian called me back that very evening on his off hours to discuss my collection. He was extremely knowledgeable about MtG and especially with the card sets I was looking to sell.
I drove up the next day from NWI to meet with Dorian who spent an exceptional amount of time appraising my cards with me and walking for through his process and even showing me what certain very valuable cards were selling for in the same condition as my cards. He even took into account the distance traveled with his appraisal! I was VERY impressed with Dorian and Comic Buying Center and would highly recommend them for anyone looking to sell high value Magic cards.
Thanks Dorian and Comic Buying Center for a very special experience!
I drove up the next day from NWI to meet with Dorian who spent an exceptional amount of time appraising my cards with me and walking for through his process and even showing me what certain very valuable cards were selling for in the same condition as my cards. He even took into account the distance traveled with his appraisal! I was VERY impressed with Dorian and Comic Buying Center and would highly recommend them for anyone looking to sell high value Magic cards.
Thanks Dorian and Comic Buying Center for a very special experience!
Great experience selling my Magic the Gathering (MTG) cards today. Appreciate the knowledgeable and transparent discussion and quick transaction. A+ service. Thank you!
Mike did a fabulous job of walking us through the process and offered a fair price for all of our comics. I would highly recommend their services!
I met with Mike in regards to a collection of comic books I was selling. While they weren’t as valuable as I had hoped I felt that Mike was fair and knowledgeable about the value of comic books. I would definitely recommend the Comic Buying Center, very well organized and friendly staff.
Great communication. Very fast appraisal. Looked through all my boxes of comics and even took into consideration that there were specialty single issues which where larger and whose original value was larger than the typical comic books in the series. Was able to talk negotiate a fair price for the entire collection. Highly recommend!
Excellent experience. Very well organized. Besides, the large collection of very reasonably priced comics, were vintage video games, Pop figures and Magic the Gathering cards. Ask for Dorian. He’s the man.
Mike was excellent at getting my comic collection assessed quickly and professionally. I was given a fair price for the whole collection with no pressure to finalize the transaction. Highly recommend this business and plan to visit their store in Libertyville, Ill in the future.
This place is great! I inquired about selling some old Magic: The Gathering cards and I got a call back from Dorian (EXTREMELY knowledgable) almost instantly. Went in the next day and had the cards appraised while my first grader had fun looking at all the cool retro games and comics. Very generous offer on my cards which I accepted. Would do business again! Highly recommended for old MTG heads like me. Thanks again Dorian and team!
I sold my comic collection to the comic buying center. These guys are so incredibly knowledgeable. So very very fair with their pricing. We worked out a fair price and they wrote me a check on the spot. If I know anyone who is looking to sell collectibles I will recommend to comic buying center.
I’ve been coming to CBC for my years in Chicago. It really is the city’s best kept severer, Peter, Mike, Chris, Dorian are just amazing people and help you out with anything you need. It always is nice to have a free snack and drink too while you are hunting. This is a go to for comic book collectors, and should be a stop for anyone who’s visiting Chicago!
Always friendly and super clean store and the staff is very informed and great prices and willing to work with you ..go and see this amazing store!!
this is the best place in the world for the classic video games and there comic collection is so vast anybody can find something to enjoy and the staff is so helpful and friendly it’s like talking with friends- Griffin
Nice store with lots of great deals. Excellent service, fair deal on trade in, fast appraisal. Would recommend. Thanks Mike
Professional and resourceful business! I will recommend for special Star Wars collector gifts and wide variety of comic books!
Massive stock of comic books. Also trade paperbacks and games. Very cool place and the thebpeople there are extremely friendly.
Mike, Pete, and Dorian (sp?) were fantastic to deal with!! These folks really know their stuff about comics AND video games, and were really great people on top of it. Highly recommended if you have a video game or comic (or Magic the Gathering!!) need! Check them out and give them a call! A++ experience!
Has a pleasant comic and MTG card selling experience. Mike and Dorian sat with us in a room dedicated to the process, and went through all our items. They used live pricing estimates, sharing their on line sources with us, and explained their offers. They were friendly, efficient, and knowledgeable.
Friendly, inviting, helpful, and fair. I am very happy that I found Comic Buying Center. They have efficiently reviewed and fairly assessed my collections and handled everything with respect and care. They quickly gained my trust and I highly recommend them to anyone looking to appraise and/or sell their own collections.
The epitome of geeked out Comic Capitalism. For those of us who grew up with these incredible pieces of art AND storytelling, this is the quintessential distribution center for collectors and just plain nostalgic folk. There are incredible displays for the wandering eye and bins and bins of cost effective illustrated options. Every imaginable comic and illustrated novel….available here. Collectibles galore. Sometimes it feels like a capitalistic museum from the Marvel and DC universe. Enjoy this little gem on the outskirts of Libertyville, right off of RT176 coupla blocks east of RT21.
Nice place good people…but only 50% for your best…brought in 490.he took 20.payed half what worth.. Should at least do 65% and the rest wanted to pay 150…only go if your desperate..can sell higher end comics yourself. Or pass them down.kind of felt stupid letting comics go I had 50 years go like that.and only the best ones.
I wanted to give a big shout out to the Comic Buying Center in Libertyville. I recently decided to part with a 251 issue comic book collection that I inherited 7 years ago when my father passed. I first did my own research with the Overstreet Guide. I subsequently brought my collection in for a free evaluation. I interacted with Mike and Pete and they were extremely knowledgable and professional. I felt that they offered me a fairly valuation for my collection which contained some rare and marketable issues. I chose to seek out a second opinion from a local comic book seller which was a nightmare. I was advised that I had nothing of value and offered $100 for my entire collection. This was either a dishonest attempt to obtain my collection for essentially nothing or the owner doesn’t really know his business. I returned to the Comic Buying Center and was paid $5,000 for my collection. Pete is a very honest and professional individual and I would recommend him and his business without hesitation. As my story above illustrates, there are many others in this business who are not so forthright. Choose carefully!
Very easy to work with. Gave me a fair price on a large collection of modern comics and graphic novels. Would definitely work with them again.
Friendly and very welcoming place.
I brought in my old TMNT collection to get it appraised. Peter is very knowledgeable. Taught me a bunch!
Made me a fair offer with a great explanation of how he came to that.
Cool place to check out for the serious or casual collector especially if you are looking for back issues.
I brought in my old TMNT collection to get it appraised. Peter is very knowledgeable. Taught me a bunch!
Made me a fair offer with a great explanation of how he came to that.
Cool place to check out for the serious or casual collector especially if you are looking for back issues.
This is the place to deal with professionals! I recently dealt with Peter and Dorian with my sale.They we’re both so knowledgeable and professional- not to mention friendly. The whole staff has the same professionalism.Peter was more than fair with his offer.He laid out ally options and with no pressure.They really do care about you as a customer…I highly recommend doing business with them if you are looking to buy or sell- go in and be amazed!! Their showroom is very impressive.They also offer free beverages! Such a pleasure to deal with. I am so happy I found them!!! And will be doing more business with them.5 stars across the board Thank all of you!
Peter is awesome. I highly recommend his shop. I had a large comic collection that I had been hanging on to since the mid-90s, and I finally decided to sell it. As he appraised my collection, Peter took the time to explain to me what some of the key comics were worth and why. I found him to be very knowledgeable and very honest ( something you won’t always find from people in his line of work).
Had some comics to sell for a relative. Explained the whole process up front. Great, easy, smooth, experience. Thank you.
I came here on my lunch break and this place is awesome! Staff was super friendly. The selection of comics and trades was insane. Even their binder of MTG cards had a great selection. I plan on going back very soon!
Wonderful experience at Comic Buying Center today! I contacted Mike and we set an appointment to possibly sell my comics. Mike was so knowledgeable and friendly. He showed me around the store, offered me something to drink and walked me thru the buying process. HONEST. Very refreshing to experience. He offered me a great and fair price and we were done. It was so relaxed we ended up talking a little about our lives outside of comics. Great time today. Thanks Mike!
I was recently tasked with selling the large comics collection (around 7000 comics), of a relative’s estate. It was almost all DC silver age comics. Peter came to my home in Wisconsin and carefully walked through the process with me and made a very fair offer that day. His knowledge, experience and thoughtfulness made this a very pleasant experience. I’m so glad I called them first!
This place is amazing! I can spend hours going through the hundreds of back issues in stock and constantly find amazing issues for cheap. I love visiting this place!
Very pleasant people to deal with. First time doing business with and couldn’t have been more smooth.
They drove out to me to buy my comics. They were very fair, knowledgeable, and friendly. I plan on continuing to do business with them and I would strongly recommend them if you are buying or selling comics!
Very impressed with this center, and their expertise in comics. Mike and the team were very welcoming, from my initial phone call to my store visit. Gave me a very fair price on my small collection, and showed me cool items that I hope to return to take a look at.
Thank you!
Thank you!
Selling my collection to these guys was a very pleasant experience. I got a fair price for my comics and, I’m glad they’ll go to collectors who’ll value them. I highly recommend this company.
Randomly stopped by because we saw the “Comics 4 Less Store OPEN” sign on the street. A little weird to get into the building because there’s no other signage, but the comics inside were awesome! $2 for issues, $5 for trades. Great quality and selection. Really nice guys too! Definitely will come back.
Contact us anytime
Phone
Opening Hours
Mon - Sat: 10am - 5pm